Grading the Deadline Addition of Troy Stecher for the Oilers

Commenting on the acquisition, analyst David Staples highlights the importance of adding a skilled defenseman like Stecher to the Oilers’ roster, emphasizing the need for more puck-movers amidst the team’s already-heavy defensive lineup. Staples sees Stecher as a valuable depth player who brings a slighty different element.

Coyotes’ analyst Jordan Schmaltz, who broke the news of the trade, praises Stecher’s qualities, describing him as a fierce competitor with the “heart of a lion.” Schmaltz emphasizes Stecher’s ability to excel in retrieving pucks, showcasing a quick and precise first touch, regardless of the pressure he faces from opposing players. He noted his more-than-adequate puck-handling skills.

Analyst J.D. Burke of EP Rinkside acknowledged Stecher’s smaller stature but underscored his capabilities as a puck-moving, defensive defenseman, capable of slotting into a No. 4 or 5 role.

Finally, Thomas Drance of The Athletic draws parallels between Stecher and former Oiler Andrew Ference, noting that due to his size, teams often aim to slot him lower in the lineup. However, Drance highlights Stecher’s versatility and consistent ability to surpass expectations.

Why Are Some Oilers Fans Concerned About the Trade?

While the move to acquire Stecher is generally praised, there are counter-arguments suggesting that it might not be enough to address critical needs in other areas. Specifically the second-line right wing and second-pairing right defenseman positions were a hole GM Ken Holland was trying to fill. Because Edmonton took all of Stecher’s salary in the trade, there’s not much room to make other moves and the general consensus among Oilers’ analysts is that Edmonton is done.

This has left fans questioning if Holland has done enough, which might be the lone reason the Stecher move isn’t being universally praised.

The Oilers’ acquisitions of Adam Henrique and Sam Carrick are acknowledged as smart additions, but the absence of upgrades in certain positions leaves room for some disappointment. The Oilers now face the challenge of managing their remaining cap space, with Stecher’s $1.1 million cap hit leaving little space for an upgrade in the top six.

All in all, this trade should get a B+. But, because it probably signifies the end of Holland wheeling and dealing, that lowers it to a B-, maybe even a C+. That might not be fair, but when other teams in the Pacific Division are loading up, fans expect the Oilers to do the same. They made moves, but Holland left questions unanswered.